|
Post by beyond on Aug 9, 2005 15:42:37 GMT -5
Ok, I just said that Harry might not necessarly have to die. I mean, people who get the Dementor's kiss performed on them don't die, they only lose their soul. So, a soul can obviously be destroyed without killing the person that it is in.
|
|
skye
2nd Year
~ravenclaw~Charms teacher~Hogwarts ghost~MoM Dept. of Mysteries~[M:-155]
Posts: 395
|
Post by skye on Aug 9, 2005 15:45:37 GMT -5
but without a sould the person won't be the same.
|
|
|
Post by beyond on Aug 9, 2005 15:49:26 GMT -5
I know that, lol.
But I'm sure there would be a way to destroy one of the souls inside of Harry? Also, just for the point of discussion, you have to assume that if Harry was a Horcrux, he would kill himself because he loves others so much that he would know he was saving them from Voldemort's return.
I don't think that would happen though, I think if he is a Horcrux, then he would find a way only to destroy the piece of Voldemort's soul.
|
|
skye
2nd Year
~ravenclaw~Charms teacher~Hogwarts ghost~MoM Dept. of Mysteries~[M:-155]
Posts: 395
|
Post by skye on Aug 9, 2005 15:55:08 GMT -5
yea, i don't think jkr will kill harry in the seventh book. i mean come on its a childrens novel so everything will turn out right in the end.
|
|
|
Post by beyond on Aug 9, 2005 22:21:02 GMT -5
it may be a childrens novel, but I mean, she has killed off so many people already, killing Harry is not out of the picture. Once again though, I think Harry will live.
|
|
|
Post by Mary9836 on Aug 9, 2005 22:21:10 GMT -5
lol!! For real...killing Harry would spark ALOT of mad kids! heck even adults would complain!! There's just no way Harry will die...NO WAY! lol...well i hope he doesn't!
|
|
|
Post by Bo on Aug 10, 2005 8:49:59 GMT -5
I don't think Harry will die but one thing we should all realize about J.K. is that she writes what she comes up with whether the fans like it or not. If any of you write you know what I mean sometimes it may not turn out picture perfect but that's just how it happens then you have to write it. I mean everybody was really mad when Dumbledore and Sirius died but I don't think she'll change it just to appease us. ya know?
|
|
|
Post by pepe on Aug 10, 2005 15:46:55 GMT -5
Ok, first off; for those of you who think that if Harry is a Horcrux and will have to kill him self, slow down. Remember when dumbledore said something about when voldemort was killed, he took part of his soul out of one of the horcruxes?? So that would mean that if harry destroyed all the horcruxes other than himself, then killed voldemort, the last bit of voldemorts soul would come out. Also, for those of you who don't think that J.K would kill off harry, think again. She has said many times that "when writing, it's important that you please yourself first, and worry about everyone else later." if killing harry makes her happy, it will happen.
|
|
|
Post by beyond on Aug 10, 2005 17:15:46 GMT -5
Good, everyone is realizing the JKR will do exactly what she thinks she must. lol
If Harry actually did have to kill himself to get rid of a Horcrux, he would obviously have to kill himself at the same time that he kills Voldemort, or Voldemort would live through the piece that had been in Harry.
|
|
wfire
Muggle
Nervous First Year Student
Posts: 29
|
Post by wfire on Aug 10, 2005 19:21:28 GMT -5
no, harry isn't a horcroux....LV put the pieces of his soul in OBJECTS!! did anyone read the book..lol yes we did, and nagini is believed to be a horcrux by DD, and DD said that living people could be horcruxes but LV would have to trust them a lot. Remember? That is why I don't believe Harry is one. Let's throw Snape in the mix though and say maybe he is a horcrux. ha
|
|
|
Post by beyond on Aug 10, 2005 20:41:45 GMT -5
no, harry isn't a horcroux....LV put the pieces of his soul in OBJECTS!! did anyone read the book..lol yes we did, and nagini is believed to be a horcrux by DD, and DD said that living people could be horcruxes but LV would have to trust them a lot. Remember? That is why I don't believe Harry is one. Let's throw Snape in the mix though and say maybe he is a horcrux. ha kk, I said the theory is based on Voldemort accidently making Harry a Horcrux. Just to clear things up
|
|
|
Post by Bo on Aug 11, 2005 18:29:22 GMT -5
quot; if killing harry makes her happy, it will happen. I don' think she will kill off Harry because there would be no point would there and a story always has a point. Making it realisticlly sad would make sense it is like life and war but killing Harry just wouldn't make sense.
|
|
pepeguadalupe
Muggle
While everyone's lost, the battle is won, with all these things that I've done[M:-114]
Posts: 85
|
Post by pepeguadalupe on Aug 11, 2005 20:55:22 GMT -5
quot; if killing harry makes her happy, it will happen. I don' think she will kill off Harry because there would be no point would there and a story always has a point. Making it realisticlly sad would make sense it is like life and war but killing Harry just wouldn't make sense. How do you figure? It would make the book very interesting that if the end of the story, Harry died. How does that mean that there would be no point to the story???
|
|
|
Post by beyond on Aug 11, 2005 21:00:48 GMT -5
Yes, like it has been said, if JKR thinks that is what will make the correct ending to the story, that is what will happen. It is what she thinks that matters, not what we think. And Harry Potter will be one of the greatest book series ever written no matter how it is ended.
|
|
pepeguadalupe
Muggle
While everyone's lost, the battle is won, with all these things that I've done[M:-114]
Posts: 85
|
Post by pepeguadalupe on Aug 12, 2005 10:35:05 GMT -5
Thank you Beyond. Finally someone understands that it really doesn't matter at all what we THINK or WANT to happen. It's what JK wants.
|
|