|
Post by BreAnn on Sept 19, 2006 21:38:54 GMT -5
This thought came to me while reading HBP, and I don't recall it being on here anywhere, and if it is, please redirect me to it.
So anyways, ya all know how in HBP harry finds the Prince's book and to Slughorn he is amazing at potions "A natural just like his mother" he says, and well we all know snape was great a natural at potions. So could Lilly and snape be related? Maybe thats why he hated James, cause he was trying to get Lilly. And that could maybe be why Voldemort didn't want to kill her (assuming your beleive the 'snape is evil' theory). Cause he could know of snape and lilly's family relations and hope that that could sway her to his side.
|
|
|
Post by ravenclaw18 on Sept 20, 2006 9:58:24 GMT -5
But Harry was only good at Potions because of the Prince's book, so he isn't a natural at all. I do see what you're getting at, but I can't quite picture it myself...
|
|
|
Post by BreAnn on Sept 20, 2006 14:22:36 GMT -5
im not pointing out the fact that to slughorn harry is good, I'm pointing out that slughorn says several times that harry's mom was good at potions.
|
|
|
Post by Netthug on Sept 21, 2006 12:56:21 GMT -5
i getcha Bre, and i thought of it before but i cant see Voldemort not wanting to kill Lily because thats what Snape would want it coz hes the kinda guy that would do whatever he wants and doesnt care for anyone
|
|
|
Post by ...Ben... on Oct 4, 2006 9:51:43 GMT -5
i get whot u mean and i think tis a gd theory, but its very unlikely
|
|
|
Post by Bo on Oct 4, 2006 15:29:00 GMT -5
Well, I think Snape and Lilly may be related but the only reason you offered I would agree with was that may explain why Snape hated James. Voldermort knew Lily would never come to his side even if Snape was related to her, no more than he would try to sway the Weasleys. Also I do not think them both being good in potions hints at a relation. i could be wrong but thats just a big line to draw. Hermione is good a tpotions too, but she's not related to him just because she's a good student. Unless they were brother and sister I don't even think traits would be that likely to be shared.
|
|
|
Post by ...Ben... on Oct 13, 2006 11:41:56 GMT -5
they would have 2 be twins if they were siblings...
|
|
|
Post by summertimefun6 on Dec 28, 2006 13:02:07 GMT -5
i don't they're related BreAnn sorry but Lily is a muggle born and Snape is 'half-blood' his mom was a pureblood witch who married a muggle. Snape said in OoP that he didn't want help from a 'mudblood' so i don't think they're related. Good theory but i think it's just something they have incommon. I wont deny that Snape wanted Lily because that's something I can see
*Tanya*
|
|
|
Post by rupertmentalist on Jun 11, 2007 16:22:54 GMT -5
and hermione is snapes daughter...lol i mean it cud b but im not so sure bout this theory but then again she was always standing up for snape maybe it was lik a sisterly sort of protection but idk w/e i just cant see snape and lilly related??but there is also NO resemblance at all in any way
|
|
|
Post by weasley on Aug 6, 2007 12:45:29 GMT -5
i think snape must hv jus seen lily in skool n loved her.......this is more probable na..........lol
|
|
|
Post by Mary9836 on Aug 6, 2007 14:31:07 GMT -5
Well i'm for one glad that Snape and lily are not related because first of all....ewww...and second of all that would make everyone related to everyone and this isn't a soap opera...well actually it kinda is..haha
|
|
|
Post by summertimefun6 on Aug 7, 2007 22:13:31 GMT -5
Well i'm for one glad that Snape and lily are not related because first of all....ewww...and second of all that would make everyone related to everyone and this isn't a soap opera...well actually it kinda is..haha omg first of all Mary, this post just totally and completely made my day. second, i'm glad too. third, i'm laughing so hard at the eww part that i'm having trouble writting this right now. *Tanya*
|
|
|
Post by Mary9836 on Aug 8, 2007 14:22:03 GMT -5
lol! Glad you got a kick out of it! I for one am glad that Snape is only related to himself....plus, i mean Petunia and Vernon already felt ashamed of their wizard kin...could you imagine if Snape joined the crew too...and then announced his love for his distant cousin or something...(double ewww)....Petunia would flop over with shock!
|
|
ajd13
Muggle
0mgz0rs an active member!!!
Posts: 32
|
Post by ajd13 on Aug 16, 2007 18:13:21 GMT -5
hermione cant be sanpes daughter because first we saw both her parents in the second movie and the fact that she is a "mudblood". if hermione was snapes daughter then she would get at least 1/4 of the pureblood status and maybe more depending on who snape was married to..
|
|
|
Post by Mary9836 on Aug 16, 2007 21:11:49 GMT -5
plus Snape never had a family besides his parents so theres another reason hermione can't be his daughter
|
|