Horcruxes - New Theory!!

[summertimefun6]

So i'm reread HBP and I came up with this new theory about the horcruxes. I'll start off with what Dumbledore said were possible ones

Dumbledore - ring, diary, part in his body now, something of Ravenclaw's or Gryffindor's, locket, nagini, and the cup

alright i'm pretty sure on all of these except one. I personally don't think Voldemort ever found anything of Ravenclaw's or Gryffindor's. I think that's why he wanted to come back to Hogwarts to teach so he could find them. I don't think he ever personally reach seven horcruxes. I think he only seperated his soul 5 times, these means the 6th was in his body.

When Voldemort went to kill harry he didn't have 6 here's my theory on wat the horcruxes are...

ring, diary, nagini, cup locket, part in his body right now and the part that was killed when he tried to kill Harry.

i think when he went to kill harry a part of his soul was lost that day or in other words, killed. He made it all the way to Romania so lets say one of his Horcruxes was there. That would explain a lot. So my theory is that Harry only has 3 horcruxes left now 4.

Anyone else get what i'm saying b/c i'll explain it again if you don't.




*Tanya*

[bookluver14]

okay. I was listening to MuggleCast-- and they said something pretty interesting that goes along with this.

They said something about a baton, which a i got to mean as Ravenclaw's.. I really have to re-listen to it..

But anyway are you saying that Harry, is indeed a Horcrux? Because, at times I do actually believe it. And i do believe that one is still intact in Voldemort himself, otherwise how could he 'live'-- and so harry really has one less than some people say. I do agree with all of your choices for the horcruxes... But i don't think i agree with your theory that one has already died.

It does, however, make perfect sence. And of course no one would know-- because he would want to keep that secret. But it just doesn't make sence... okay. well, it does.

Good theory... I just don't know if I agree with it 100%

[ravenclaw18]

I had a crazy theory at one point. I think I used it in a fanfic or something, but anyway, the crazy theory was that Snape is a Horcrux.

[summertimefun6]

bookie, i get exactly what your saying and i'm not totally sure if Harry's a horcrux because I think we would of seen more of Voldemort evil side if that was true and the protection his mom put on him would of prevented it but then again i'm not totally sure

ravie, that's a totally crazy idea, i never would of thought of it




*Tanya*

[ravenclaw18]

Ah, but the thing about HP is that crazy theories are more likely to be correct

[Mary9836]

I really don't wanna think that Harry is a horcrux thingy...really i am against that theory usually BUT...maybe he made Harry a horcrux by accident...because in GOF when his wand went crazy there were shadows, a little peice of everyone he had murdered...and she always makes a point of telling us how much Voldemort and Harry are alike...wands, not pure blood, a leader, strong magical powers, parseltongue...ect. so it's possible...

It always makes me wonder how different Harry would be if it hadn't happened...would he be as talented or strong willed without VOldemort in his life!

i still don't want Harry to be horcrux though! but it's a theory!

[summertimefun6]

ravie you make a huge point and i guess anything is possible




*Tanya*

[rupertmentalist]

yo he did end up cummin bak to hogwarts and i think he did find sumthin of ravenclaws hello ppl mirror of erised do these words mean anythin to u??i mean if u can put a stone into it then y not a piece of soul&i think it was ravenclaws mirror because in the book it mentions it standing on large CLAWED feet but ya no this cud b complete bull but who knows im just sayin...